Costa Rica / Food

Paella Ingredient Challenge

Donny K's Paella

Donny K’s Paella

Paella is a regional dish my husband, Don, learned to make in Spain years ago when he was in the business of buying and selling horses that took him all over the world. He made the acquaintance of the beautiful, enchanting “Sangria Lady” and the wizened paella chef touting their wares on the coast of Valencia. Whether the enticement was the food, the wine, or the lady is anybody’s guess (I’m going with the lady) but the result is the same: magic!

He has adopted this as his signature dish which he makes for the lucky diners who happen to be in his circle when the urge to make one strikes. The key ingredient, aside from saffron, is chorizo. Here in Costa Rica we have yet to find the right chorizo. We have chased down every lead given by friends, acquaintances, and strangers. We’ve been to fancy markets in Escazu, tiny mom ‘n pop places, tiendas and carnicerias as far away as Parrita in search of the spicy sausage that when simmered in the paella pan emits a burnt orange oil that gives the dish the right color, flavor and consistency.

At one point, we bought pig intestines and made our own. We got a Mexican chorizo recipe from the internet, followed the directions exactly and still, it wasn’t right.

Home-made chorizo

Home-made chorizo

Chorizo links

Chorizo links

I would think, being a dish from Spain, the Spanish style chorizo would be authentic. Nope. Too dry.

Last year we went to California for a quick visit in the Sacramento area. We hunted down a Mexican market and bought ten pounds of chorizo. We split it into two separate triple zip-locked baggies, and we each shoved a package into our suitcase. If one got busted, maybe the other would make it. We did the happy dance when we got home with both bundles of chorizo present and accounted for. We made the guest list for the dinner party the following evening. It would take most of the next day to gather the rest of the ingredients.

We had purchased a magnificent paella pan at a restaurant supply house in San Jose named “Tips”. Here you can find quality gourmet accoutrement. It will cost almost double compared to U.S. prices, but at least you can find most things.

It’s a challenge to find the right food stuff. Coming from the northern coast of California, I took for granted going into Phil’s Fish Market in Moss Landing, where everything is  available in one spot; lobster, scallops, shrimp, fresh fish and squid. In Costa Rica, if you’re lucky, PriceSmart will have clams and mussels in the frozen section. Automercado might have saffron although the last time we bought it, the price was too cheap, so I thought it must not be real. Saffron is made from the stems of flowers which makes it labor intensive and pricey.

Chicken thighs are easy to find, but getting the right cut is another story. The first time we bought them from the butcher in Atenas we didn’t pay attention expecting the “muslo”(thigh) to be the meaty chunk above the leg. Instead, we got a bony cut inappropriate for paella. I made soup and went shopping for more thighs. The recipe calls for six. I bought three whole chickens and cut it up myself. At a surprising $8.00 per chicken, this dish was getting expensive. I had enough extra chicken parts to start a soup business. Hmmmmm….Carole Jean’s Jewish Penicillin; with matzoh balls, of course.

Chef Don put together a scrumptious paella, charming the dinner guests as he manned the special gas burner we bought for the occasion. Turns out we had an abundance of ingredients – too many to fit in the pan. The solution? A larger pan! And more dinner guests.

Huge paella pan still in wrapper!

Huge paella pan still in wrapper!

Play your cards right and get on the invitation list. When it comes to Don’s paella, you don’t want to be on Seinfeld’s “Soup Nazi” bad side: “No paella for you!”

One way to get on the list: smuggle in some Mexican chorizo. Another way: sneak in some lobsters, my favorite ingredient! Do either, and I’ll make the sangria!

By the way, the paella recipe will be in my cookbook, “It’s the Parsley” which is coming soon.

8 thoughts on “Paella Ingredient Challenge

  1. Having heard about this famous Paella, I would happily smuggle some home made chorizo from El Salchicero in Santa Cruz, it is the best! That means a trip to Costa Rica for another visit. What a fantastic excuse to hang out with you too! An aside for Don, you ROCK.


  2. Hey, good to hear that the paella is the favorite Spanish dish for you!! We love it too! I use also rabbit. (Automercado)
    I still regret till today I did not bring my paella burner and pan…….I make it in a big wadjang with flat bottom which I brought from Indonesia. I use safran and tumaric for the colour.
    We had a House for 23 years in Spain in a valley off the Costa Blanca coast and lived there for 12 years before coming to Costa Rica.

    I have used the mixed frozen sea food from Price Smart which goes very well with the paella as a base for the fishy taste and add fresh lobsters, prawns whatever you will find in the fish market in central SJ. Buy chicken at the market on friday in Atenas. The lady there has good chicken parts…..I know that it is very hard to get chorizo here thats why I never bothered to find it…

    There is a guy, named Eddy, who comes every 2 weeks to Atenas and delivers at home fresh fish, huge prawns and I guess lobster to order…… Have probably to order them! He comes also to Roca Verfe. His phone number is. 86 54 07 61

    Hope this helps! Liena.


  3. Just want to say that the picture of Don looks like it should go on a book cover. It is great! And I think Paella is one of the best dishes ever!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s